
Last Friday, I went to the mosque as usual for Friday prayers. Everything seemed normal—the crowd, the sermon, the atmosphere. But something caught my attention during the khutbah. The khatib, while praying and reciting short verses during the prayer, suddenly sounded like he was crying. His voice trembled, he paused often, as if he was deeply emotional and spiritually moved.
But here’s the strange part: I didn’t feel anything. It didn’t touch me at all. It wasn’t that I wasn’t paying attention, or that my heart was closed. It just felt… off. It didn’t sound like genuine emotion. It felt more like he was trying to cry, or maybe thought he should cry to make the moment feel more dramatic. And the truth is, it didn’t connect. It felt like acting.
And this wasn’t the first time I’ve heard a khatib cry during a sermon. But this one felt different—it felt empty. Like he was just doing his job, checking the boxes of what a “moving” khutbah should be, but without truly feeling it.

As a lecturer myself, this reminds me of something I often see in classrooms. Many lecturers show up, open their slides, read through the material, give out assignments, and leave. That’s it. No passion, no energy, no attempt to connect with students. Just doing the job because they have to. And guess what? Students can feel that too. They may not say it out loud, but they know when a teacher is just going through the motions.

It’s kind of like cooking. Two people can follow the exact same recipe, but the food will taste different. Why? Because one cooks with heart, with joy, with care. The other just wants to get it done. You can taste the difference—and it’s the same with sermons, lectures, or any kind of communication. People can feel when something is genuine, and when it’s just an act.
Students are not robots. They have feelings. They can tell when you’re teaching from the heart or just doing your duty. Just like I could tell that the khatib’s tears didn’t feel real—not because I wanted to judge him, but because my heart didn’t respond. Real emotion has a frequency. When it’s true, it reaches others. When it’s forced, it falls flat.
I’m not here to criticize that khatib. Maybe he truly was feeling something. But if the emotion doesn’t reach the people listening, then maybe something’s missing—maybe the delivery, maybe the intention. True sincerity doesn’t need to be dramatic. It just needs to be honest.
And that goes for all of us—whether we’re teachers, speakers, preachers, or just people trying to share something meaningful. If our heart isn’t in it, our message won’t land. It’ll just be noise—loud, maybe—but meaningless.